youth

Rain or Shine

Commissioned by an open adoption agency, Rain or Shine tells the story of Finn, a young boy in an open adoption who looks forward to gathering with his extended family to celebrate his eighth birthday.  The plotline focuses on how the family will salvage the party if it rains on the big day, but the real strength of the book lies in its depiction of a healthy open adoption.

There were several nice touches:

  • Finn does not make sharp distinctions between his adoptive family and his birth family.  The two are integrated together into a single extended family for him.
  • Finn's grandmother on his birth mom’s side is an active participant in his life, reflecting the many open adoptions which involve multiple generations.
  • Both Finn’s adoptive parents and his birth mom talk appreciatively and affectionately about one another. They acknowledge and affirm both the nature and nurture portions of Finn's identity, pointing out traits that come from each side of his family tree.
  • Finn enjoys spending time alone with his birth mom and feels comfortable enough with her to tell her about his secret thumb-sucking, something he's previously only shared with his parents.
  • It’s mentioned that Finn’s birth mom did not attend his seventh party because she was having “a hard time” that year. Finn also expresses a desire to have contact with his birth dad, who the family hasn't seen since Finn was an infant.  I appreciated the subtle acknowledgment that open adoptions can be positive and fulfilling despite not being "perfect." These also create openings for parents (birth or adoptive) to talk with their children about adoption-related disappointments.

The simple story and fun details will engage young readers.  Sensitive and well-written, Rain or Shine is a welcome addition to the small but growing list of children’s books about open adoption.    Hopefully its high price point will go down in the future so that even more families can enjoy it.

Probably for ages around 4-8.  The characters are Caucasian and the adoptive parents are a heterosexual couple.

Publisher:

Xlibris Corporation

ISBN:

978-1-4257-7812-5

Pages:

34

Price:

$22 (paperback), $32 (hardcover)

Rating:

9

Pugnose Has Two Special Families

"Pugnose Has Two Special Families" isn't the slickest children's book about adoption you'll ever see. It's bound with staples, needs a bit of editing, and sometimes tells when it could show. But it is a nice resource for open adoption families for several reasons.

Author:

Karis Kruzel

Publisher:

R-Squared Press

ISBN:

0964103559

Pages:

16

Price:

$7.95

Rating:

8

Review:

"Pugnose Has Two Special Families" isn't the slickest children's book about adoption you'll ever see. It's bound with staples, needs a bit of editing, and sometimes tells when it could show. But it is a nice resource for open adoption families for several reasons.

First, the main character is an adopted mouse who has ongoing contact with his first parents. "I have two families--my birthfamily and my adoptive family," he says. "When we are all together, it seems like one big family." Children's books that mirror the ongoing openness of many domestic adoptions are not easy to find. It is nice to see it reflected here.

Second, the first parents are actual characters in the story. Pugnose's first parents are shown several times, both before and after his birth. We see them with interacting with Pugnose as he grows and he talks about traits he shares with them. Even more unusually, the first father is included.

Third, it acknowledges that Pugnose had a history prior to his adoption. So many adoption books for kids begin at the point of placement and make it seem as if their adoption was a forgone conclusion from the moment of their conception. Pugnose's birthmom tells him stories about when he was growing inside her and how much she loved him. He tells us, "She thought about trying to be my mama herself, and she thought about adoption, too. She finally chose open adoption so she could see me as I was growing up."

Finally, it touches on the sorrow that accompanies adoption. Everyone is happy Pugnose has been born, but also sad. His first parents are sad they are not ready to parent him and because they will miss him. His adoptive family is sad because they know his first family is hurting. It's a good example of how sadness can be acknowledged even in what is overall a positive presentation of adoption.

Listed for ages ranging from 4-10, but probably more suitable for kids 2-8. As with every adoption book, not all the details will apply to every family's situation, but the general outline of the story will likely fit most domestic open adoptions.

Megan's Birthday Tree: A Story About Open Adoption

A favorite of many open adoption families, "Megan's Birthday Tree" tells the story of a little girl being reassured of her first mother's love for her. Her first mom, Kendra, planted a tree when Megan was born, and each year on Megan's birthday Kendra decorates the growing tree and sends a picture to Megan.

Author:

Laurie Lears, Bill Farnsworth (illustrator)

Publisher:

Albert Whitman & Co.

ISBN:

0807550361

Pages:

32

Rating:

9

Review:

A favorite of many open adoption families, "Megan's Birthday Tree" tells the story of a little girl being reassured of her first mother's love for her. Her first mom, Kendra, planted a tree when Megan was born, and each year on Megan's birthday Kendra decorates the growing tree and sends a picture to Megan. When Megan learns that Kendra is moving to a new city, she worries that Kendra will forget about her without the tree to remind her. The story follows Megan as she searches for ways to replace the tree, and culminates with her sharing her fears with Kendra and being assured of their bond.

An excellent book for any family involved in an open adoption, this could be comforting for children in closed or semi-open adoptions as well. The story focuses on Megan and her relationship with Kendra, with the adoptive parents playing a supportive, but minor role. Megan has complex feelings about her adoption appropriate to her age.

Ages 4-10. The characters are Causasian. Megan's first father is not mentioned.